Reservation
+1 407-568-4300
Visit Us
16869 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32820, United States
Hello dear
Welcome to Papa Gio's Pizzeria of East Orlando
At Papa Gio's Pizzeria of East Orlando, authentic Italian flavors meet heartfelt hospitality in a quaint setting. Founded by passionate Italian chefs, this pizzeria serves an array of gourmet pizzas, featuring the beloved Spinach & Tomato and the savory Meat Lover's varieties. Diners rave about the quality, freshness, and generous portions, with standout dishes like Chicken Marsala and Sicilian-style pizzas. Locals appreciate the welcoming vibe and attentive service, making it a favorite spot for both dine-in and delivery. Whether you're indulging in their creamy cheesecake or enjoying a classic slice, Papa Gio's promises a delightful culinary experience that feels like home.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Cheese Pizza
Chicken Melanzane
Linguine & Fresh Clams
Lobster Ravioli
About
Papa Gio's Pizzeria of East Orlando
Welcome to Papa Gio's Pizzeria of East Orlando, a hidden gem nestled at 16869 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32820. This charming spot, often characterized as a "hole in the wall," serves as a culinary haven for those in search of authentic Italian flavors. With a phone call away at +1 407-568-4300, you're just moments from experiencing comforting dishes that evoke the rich traditions of Italy.
As you step inside, the warm atmosphere infused with Italian hospitality envelops you. It's not just a restaurant; it's a tangible piece of Italy in East Orlando, run by passionate Italians who are dedicated to serving nothing less than excellence. Diners have raved about the homemade soups, noting the remarkable taste of the Chicken Noodle and the delightful Italian Wedding Soup, rich in greens and meat.
- Gourmet Pasta: Their gourmet pasta selection is a standout. The Fettuccine Carbonara, made with a creamy white sauce, perfectly balances the savory notes of ham and peas. For those who crave seafood, the Linguine & Fresh Clams with your choice of red or white sauce is a paradise on a plate.
- The Lobster Ravioli and Penne Alla Vodka are exquisite options that elevate your dining experience, particularly with the vodka’s splash in the vodka sauce providing a delightful punch to classic flavors.
Among the lunchtime offerings, the cold subs have garnered notable praise. Diners rave about the Prosciutto & Fresh Grande Mozzarella Sub, perfect for a quick bite yet fulfilling enough for the hungriest patron. Likewise, the “Godfather Sub” is a hearty combination of flavors that Italian food enthusiasts can appreciate.
Don't just take my word for it; the reviews speak volumes. Patrons like pemehl highlight the fair prices paired with high-quality pizzas and pastas, while Carol Persia, a transplant from Philly, expressed her excitement about discovering authentic pizza ingredients, both for dine-in and delivery. Theresa N. appreciates the friendly staff and the cleanliness, underlining that Papa Gio’s is a must-visit for lunch.
For dessert, the cheesecake deserves a special mention. As Jennifer Figueroa Ortiz suggests, it’s an indulgent treat you won't want to miss after savoring the savory courses.
If you're yearning for a slice of Italy that doesn’t compromise on quality or authenticity, look no further than Papa Gio's Pizzeria of East Orlando. Whether you dine in or take out, each meal crafted here sings with the essence of home-cooked Italian comfort. Your culinary adventure awaits!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Not sure about the negative reviews here? Must be one worker having a hard time lately, but the quality of this place is amazing! Fair prices for high quality pastas, pizzas, chicken and more. Never no cheap BS with greasy ahh cheese like I get at so many other places. This place doesn't miss with any part of the menu! The service is also incredible, quickly being done with great quality, with very patient staff. And for a little hole in the wall, the atmosphere is great. Great Italian place ran by Italians, in a somewhat rural area where good food like this is a little difficult for a good price. Will continue to order from here and dine in! 5 stars. ”
“ I’m from Philly. We moved to Wedgefield and stopped in for a slice. I’m so happy to have found a great pizza! We ate in and we had it delivered tonight. Happy with both experiences. Will be ordering pizza and wings for the superbowl. ”
“ Always friendly staff that makes great pizza. My favorite is the white pizza. These guys are always kind and are doing their part keeping the restaurant clean and moving efficiently. Definitely worth visiting for lunch! ”
“ Some of the best pizza I've had in a while bring me back like I'm in New york if your in the area, give it a try ”
“ Amazing food! I ordered Sicilian pepperoni slices, and garlic knots, and they were amazing. It was first time here, and I definitely will be back. I recommend you get the cheesecake as well. I promise you will love it as much as I did. ”
“ Very lovely place I’ve been going to for several years. My family usually gets the Papa Gio’s pizza that comes with everything on top. I’ve also tried the pepperoni, cheese, and meat lovers pizzas and they’re all spectacular! Would highly recommend dining in as well, as the servers are especially kind. Selena is super hard working and attentive, she always had a bright smile as she helped out other times I came in. ”
“ Ordered a Stromboli, and damn was it big. It was so damn good, too. It feed 5 people. I'm so going back again. ”
“ Pizza came hot delicious like always people don't need to change. Nothing not a darn thing. It's the best place I ever ordered from. ”